Automation & Workflows
Make vs Zapier.
Both sit in Automation & Workflows, scored on the same six pillars from the same published methodology. Here is where they actually differ.
The short answer
Too close to call on score alone — Make sits at 84.3 and Zapier at 82.5. A gap that size is inside the noise of any honest scoring model, so pick on fit rather than rank.
Make leads on value for money, momentum and capability; Zapier leads on maturity & reliability, security & compliance and integrations & ecosystem.
Make (Celonis)
84.3
Excellent
Visual automation builder with deep branching and AI steps.
- From
- Free / $9 per month (Core)
- Pricing
- Freemium
- Maturity
- Established
- Founded
- 2016
Zapier, Inc.
82.5
Excellent
8,000+ app integrations, now with AI agents and orchestration.
- From
- Free / from $19.99 per month
- Pricing
- Freemium
- Maturity
- Mature
- Founded
- 2011
Pillar by pillar
The same six pillars and fixed weights used for every tool on the site. A lead of fewer than 5 points is not called for either side — these are evidence-backed judgements, not measurements. Read the methodology.
Capability
Make by 6
Value for Money
Make by 13
Security & Compliance
Zapier by 8
Integrations & Ecosystem
Zapier by 7
Maturity & Reliability
Zapier by 9
Momentum
Make by 8
Which one, and when
Pick Make if
- →cost per unit of output is the binding constraint — it leads Value for Money by 13 points.
- →where the product will be in a year matters as much as today — it leads Momentum by 8 points.
- →the hardest end of the work is what you are buying for — it leads Capability by 6 points.
- →Complex multi-step automations
- →Ops teams replacing manual glue work
- →Budget-conscious no-code builders
The catch
- Steeper learning curve than the simplest automation tools
- Operation-based billing can spike on high-volume scenarios
Pick Zapier if
- →it has to hold up in production from day one — it leads Maturity & Reliability by 9 points.
- →compliance and data control decide it — it leads Security & Compliance by 8 points.
- →it has to fit the stack you already run — it leads Integrations & Ecosystem by 7 points.
- →Business-team automation
- →Connecting SaaS sprawl
- →AI workflows without code
The catch
- Task-based pricing gets expensive at volume
- Complex branching logic hits platform limits
What each is good at
Make
- ✓Visual canvas handles complex branching, loops and error handling
- ✓Generous operations pricing versus per-task competitors
- ✓Native AI modules drop LLM calls into any workflow
Zapier
- ✓Unmatched integration catalog, if an app exists, Zapier connects it
- ✓AI agents and Copilot make automation building conversational
- ✓SOC 2 Type 2, GDPR, CCPA; trusted by large enterprises
Other comparisons in Automation & Workflows
Comparing something else? Build your own side-by-side across any tools in the catalog.